Lacklustre NACO Messiah
As if we hadn’t already sung the Messiah through three times this year, we
got complimentary tix to see the NAC Orchestra perform Messiah tonight.
The conductor was Thierry Fischer, and man he was weak. This performance
only worked because the orchestra know this piece so well that they can carry
on without any direction at all. All he did was wave his arms in a random
fashion, totally without any relationship to the music. The chorus was on their
own, and were remarkably together given that few entries were indicated, and fewer cadences conducted, nor was any significant beating of time present during the
sixteenth-note runs that are so prevalent through Handel’s work.
The great amen was actually boring, which it should not be. It was boring
because there was no direction for any movement: neither dynamic nor tempo was
altered by this vegetative “maestro”. The CAMMAC chorus achieved more passion after 2 hours of rehearsal.
The piece was not helped by a bass soloist who believes that wide and
inaccurate vibrato will camouflage imprecise timing of long runs. The soprano
was good, as was the tenor (I’ll grant him a pitch problem once, as the rest
of his performance was grand).
As always my favorite performer was the timpanist, Ian Bernard who is a delight to watch onstage. After him would definetly be the trumpet solo, smooth as silk in “The trumpet shall sound”.
All in all, a fun evening from the point of view of being a critic, but a disappointing performance, salvaged only by the efforts of the chorus and orchestra to overcome the totally farcical direction.
|